Scourge VS Negaduck. the best, anti.

Okay. we all know that heroes, lots of times, got a villain, that is an evil version of themselves. Like Owlman, is the evil version of Batman, Bizarro, Superman you get the idea. And amongst all these, evil version of the hero villains, I got two favorites. Scourge the hedgehog. who is the evil version of Sonic the hedgehog! And, then we have Negaduck! the arch-enemy of Darkwing duck. but...which one, is the best of these two? That is something, I have been wondering. SO, no more wondering. now lets see which, one of these, two evil guys, are the best of the best. Will it be Scourge? or Negaduck!


Backstories. 

Now, this one is actually, kind of fun. Cause, heres the thing. Scourge, has always been the same guy, but he has had two identities. First it was Evil-Sonic, then it Was Scourge. So even tough, he have had two identities, he has been the same guy. While Negaduck on the other hand...while there has only been the identity, Negaduck, there have actually, been two villains, who have called themselves Negaduck! it was one, guy who actually, originated from Darkwing himself, and has been called by fans the Galvanized Negaduck. then, it was the other one, more popular, and famous negaduck, which had red and yellow clothes. which, like Scourge originated from another dimension, which was a negative/anti version universe, of the place, where the hero, lives. So..in the end, I guess it has to be a tie on this one, as both got similar backstories, of being from an anti-universe. or a Negaverse. 

Scourge: 1
Negaduck: 1

Powers. 

Now, here its kinda clear, Scourge is the winner. he got, all the same powers, as Sonic, and is a little more powerful then that. While Negaduck, on the other hand, doesn't have any real powers. he uses he's brain, to come up with plans, and he also uses, lots of weapons, and all, but those doesn't count, since, its not really powers. So, yeah..powers goes to Scourge. 

Scourge: 2
Negaduck: 1. 

Achivements. 

Okay, here is the stuff, that each villain, has achieved. Scourge, managed to take over, he's entire planet, and became its ruler. Although its not completely sure, if he actually, managed to do so. but, it hasn't been proved wrong, so for now, until its proven wrong, we have to assume, he real did it. And Negaduck? he also, managed to take over he's home world. And, another thing, both characters, has become more powerful too. like when Scourge became super Scourge, or when Negaduck became, Mega negaduck. So, once again, on achivements, I guess it has to be a tie here too!

Scourge: 3
Negaduck: 2. 

The most evil character. 

While, Scourge is evil, he has shown that he cares for a few people. Like Fiona. He is, one person, that he really likes, maybe even loves. While Negaduck, on the other hand, doesn't really love nobody. there was one, time, when he was influenced, by a love potion, but that doesn't count. And, While they have both ruled their places, that has really always been Scourge's goal. To rule, the world, and prove himself better then Sonic. but Negaduck? He is so evil, he could even challenge the joker, in an evil contest. He does, have a similar, goal like Scourge, except that Negaduck, wants to be public enemy number one. and to do this, he is willing to do, all kinds of evil things! murder, torture, stealing, anything evil! Just to become, number one, and when he has done that? he will just keep, doing, the stuff, cause he loves to do it. So, yeah. the most evil one of the two, is Negaduck!

Scourge: 3
Negaduck: 3

The smartest one. 

Scourge's plan, usually, involves, smashing stuff...and thats it. he attacked and beat everyone on he's planet, until he became ruler. he hasn't had any real master plan. even tough, he has proven time, and time, that he is not stupid. Negaduck's plans, has been lots of things. using an ancient gem, to steal other villain's powers. to trick everyone, into thinking he was darkwing duck, so he could frame Darkwing. Altough, Scourge did that at one point, when he was evil Sonic. Another thing, is that negaduck, has managed to trick, very many people. other criminals, heroes, and more. So, yeah. Negaduck, is the smartest one of the two. 

Scourge: 3
Negaduck: 4

teams. 

While, Scourge has had, different teams, working for him, Like the destructix, and the supression Squad, Negaduck, has only had one team. the fearsome five. And, even tough, Scourge's teams, have been more, powerful, and so, the supression Squad, have betrayed him. its true, that the fearsome five, tried to betray Negaduck too, but they failed. unlike the supression squad, since they weren't working for Scourge afterwards. but, yeah. Scourge gets the point for best team. 

Scourge: 4
Negaduck: 4

And there we have it. and who is the best one? Well....its a tie. each are good at somethings, or equals at other things. All in all, I guess it just comes, to which one, you prefer. I would almost say, I like Negaduck better, but thats because, He's got an awesome voice, provided by the awesome VA Jim Cummings! Seriously, what is it, he hasn't voiced that has not been awesome! but that would be unfair, to Scourge, since Scourge does not have any VA. So yeah. A tie between them. Who do you prefer?